"For God knows that in the day you eat of it your eyes will be opened and you will be like God, knowing good and evil" GENISIS 3:3-5. @ryanOptini Note RABBINIC TRADITION. The tree represents, at least to some extent, a dis-acknowledgement for the supremacy of God. Those of us who love good will seek God - this is the whole reason for it all. Amount of screen time appropriate for a baby? Why, then, did God allow Satan to tempt Adam and Eve? I want what's inside anyway. Only speculation, and consequences that resulted from the fruit being eaten. He allows us to choose between good and evil. So do we know why God decided or needed to do things this way? We also know that this life is a test and how could we be tested if we knew not what good and evil were? Now I take these versus to mean that mankind's understanding and experience of God's goodness and love, which can only lead us to praise and experience of his grace, is at a 'higher realm' after the fall and salvation of mankind, then if there was no fall at all. I think we need to be careful with semantics here. I assume you're seeking answers from people who believe in a literal tree of knowledge? 6 Reasons Why Adam and Eve’s Eating of the Forbidden Fruit Was a Terrible Transgression against God God created the world for his glory—so that his creation would live unto him, giving him praise in all things. That would be absolutely pointless if man was never presented with an opportunity to make a choice of any kind! Eating the fruit was desirous because, according to Satan, they would no longer need God to determine good and evil. 3 “It’s only the fruit from the tree at the center of the garden that we are not allowed to eat. The Garden of Eden had two trees that was designated as significant. Only in the knowledge of God’s Also, God didn't trick him. there was another command given - to tend the garden. "If God wanted Adam in Eden, why did he keep the fruit there?" That is why it was called the tree of knowledge of good and bad. How to rewrite mathematics constructively? Of course they wouldn’t know everything and they wouldn’t know good and evil. Adam had a choice, and chose to sin. The assumption (which could be addressed more fully in another question) is that it is profoundly good and ultimately enjoyable to love. When choosing a cat, how to determine temperament and personality and decide on a good fit? This makes sense because who would know what is better for someone than the one who made them. Just live your life the best you can and love unconditionally. I agree with @Jas3.1. The short answer is that God wanted us to have the knowledge of good and evil. What Satan says is partially true. The Bible says that God created Adam and Eve and put them in a beautiful garden full of trees with good fruit. I wonder how a God will create his enemy too or how a creature will try to out smart a God. (Genesis 1:26) God does not want to us to be forced to serve him, he wants us to choose this. Why would God create beings with the capacity to sin? Since God created Adam and Eve to have free will, they could think, reason, and make decisions on their own. That's the joyful message of the gospel, and the reason for our hope as Christians. By creating us with the ability to love, he created us with the ability to embrace Him and His ways, or reject Him and His ways. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. At this point, many wonder, "If God didn't create evil, then why does evil exist?" In fact, God’s Word doesn’t give a physical description of the forbidden fruit at all, except to say that it was edible and attractive (Genesis 2:9, 3:6). Why is the second coming of Christ not taught? 1 Like Re: Why Did God Make The "Forbidden Fruit" Available In Eden? The idea that he was "bound to fail the test" is false. I believe there is a deeper truth at play that accounts for why God forbade this particular fruit. Ultimately to fulfill the one (multiply and replenish) they had to partake of the fruit. Christianity Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for committed Christians, experts in Christianity and those interested in learning more. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. That is not to say that they "knew" (had a personal experiential understanding of) evil; just that they "knew" (had the knowledge of) right and wrong. Some say that the “the fruit” is allegorical to sex; somewhat counterintuitive as the only instructions given Adam and Eve other 396). blameless in his sight. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. are tempted to explain it as merely a developmental flaw, a If God wanted Adam to be fallen, why didn't He drop Adam on the face of the earth in the first place? A The actual fruit itself is not disclosed in the bible, the only record we have of this account. All things that need to happen for us to return to God. psychological weakness, a mistake, or the necessary consequence of an The promise of death for disobedience (Gen. 2:16–17) informed them that to rebel against the Lord is evil Eating from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil was sinful because before this, Adam and Eve were completely dependent on God to know what was good and what was evil. Both assumptions are false. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. The devil’s tactic is to get Eve to doubt God’s goodness; to see this restriction as an indication that God is somehow holding out on Adam and Eve. @Omar He created us with the capacity to love. Without choice what would the blood that Jesus sweat have meant. plan for man can we grasp that sin is an abuse of the freedom that God Almost a … Here's the opening live Q&A session that launched our online video training. The command itself implies a desire for obedience. You might check out the tour of the site here: Why did God make the “Forbidden Fruit” available in Eden? "You shall not eat of every tree of the garden'?" Short answer to your entire question - we don't know the will or the ways of thinking of God. What are features in signal processing using a more tangible or less abstract description. It's not that God planted "temptation" and "wickedness" before man's eyes, but rather, that He planted "a choice" in their midst. No, but we know what we were put on earth for (to be tested) and we know what the results of the tree being in Eden were, us being tested, failing, and dying, but with a Savior provided. Yes, he warned Adam and Eve never to eat the fruit, yet they did, in spite of his will, but that is not the question being asked. If you are a person who has always thought of the forbidden fruit as an apple, why do you think you thought that when the text never says that it is an apple? That is, it's simply a "made up story" that is intended to explain a spiritual truth. According to Mormons, why did God make Eve's childbearing painful? Hopefully you would only do so at appropriate times. Because of his love he wanted to give us the choice of obedence. It is God who decides what is right and what is wrong. It was His choice also not use all the power that he had, but to follow in the same obedience just as Adam should have. To Love innately requires a freedom that enables us to not love. This scenario of people rejecting God and His moral values in favor of their own moral values has continued through history and is still alive today. Note that God told Adam he could freely and willfully eat from every tree to include the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil — but — if he did eat from that tree there would be consequences. Imagine a father who forced his young child to hug him, or a husband who forced his wife to be intimate with him... what a terrible picture that would be! Did adam recieve a conscience as a result of his eating the forbidden fruit? Answer: "Forbidden" means it was a boundary which God set. Using photos obtained from academic homepages in a research seminar talk. Why was that trick necessary? -Proverbs 14:6. Adam could have chosen either way, therefore God knew it could turn out either way. “Did God really say you must not eat any of the fruit in the garden?” 2 “Of course we may eat it,” the woman told him. this section on Fate in the book Reasoning from the Scriptures (published by Jehovah's Witnesses) the subtopic: When God created Adam, did he know that Adam would sin? This is related to the most important issue that is part of the theme of the entire Bible. God creates the earth, He creates man, and then He gives man 2 commandments which both cannot be fulfilled - which leads to man falling, being tested, and dying. Why did God make the “Forbidden Fruit” available in Eden? But the temptation of Adam and Eve, and the temptation we face every day, is to decide for ourselves what is right and what is wrong, thereby, forsaking God, and making ourselves god, at least as it relates to moral authority. "Who knew better than God that Adam would fail the test?" In doing so, they also gained mortality - that they would die. When did God command Adam and Eve to be fruitful and multiply, before or after they ate the forbidden fruit? He made salvation available to everyone, and He desires that everyone would be saved. Want to improve this question? Why Was the Fruit Tempting to Adam and Eve? It makes everything seem both important and hilarious which is no good for contemplating morality and mortality. The forbidden tree was neither an arbitrary test of obedience nor a greedy restriction by a stingy God. "If the fruit was 'forbidden', why did God put it in front of man?" God makes this forbidden not arbitrarily, but because God knows a proper relationship with Himself to be necessary for eternal life. If we accept the tree as a "mere" image of freedom, the underlying question is then Why would God create beings with the capacity to sin? Why did God create oil? Along these lines we can speculate that, since we needed to be tested and couldn't be actually tested in the presence of God (remember Adam walked and talked with God in the garden) we needed someway to be separated from God AND to know good from evil. God created man with the capacity to choose to love God and walk in His good ways. and if eating the forbidden fruit gave Adam and Eve the knowledge between good and evil, then how can they possibly be held responsible for the decision to eat it in the first place? They were no longer naive dependent creatures, but rather self-aware, self-responsible beings whom God could treat more as equals than mere choiceless animals. Rather, they were actual The forbidden fruit was a test. Why was a test necessary that was bound to be failed by Adam? That issue is the sanctification of God's universal sovereignty. I realize that these answers also bring up more questions, but such is the nature of all answers and of us having limited knowledge. The fruit looked so fresh and delicious, and it would make her so wise! For further research I recommend reading in this section on Fate in the book Reasoning from the Scriptures (published by Jehovah's Witnesses) the subtopic: When God created Adam, did he know that Adam would sin? Thinking a bit more, why did God even place the tree in the Garden when he simply could have removed @Omar, God doesn't destine people to hell. I personally agree with your sentiments. One answer is that the burning of fossil fuels is simply a divine trap for unwitting and greedy human beings, who would stop at nothing to rape the earth. You can see a more careful treatise of my view (which I believe is THE correct view) here: https://d2w24jbzquz3r5.cloudfront.net/ToKoGaE.pdf. If Adam and Eve didn't know good from evil, how can we say they sinned (according to Roman Catholicism)? Does God lie? After Jesus’ crucifixion, did he go to Hell and set the captive free? He made it clear from the beginining that as our Father he would take care of us. This is an issue that God knows how to address and is the process of doing so. Now that God's sovereignty has been challenged, this issue needs to be addressed. Or are you willing to accept answers from the view that the narrative of the Fall is not meant to be taken literally? If God secretly desired disobedience when He commanded otherwise, then we could never know if He meant anything He said. Possibly one answer can be derived from Ephesians 1:3-6: This is a question I repeatedly ask myself. O necessary sin of Adam which gained for us so great a Redeemer! Why Was The Fruit Forbidden? When you get a moment, check out our. God says we must not eat it or even touch it, or we will die.”, 4“You won’t die!” the serpent hissed. 5“God knows that your eyes will be opened when you eat it. To say it another way, God did not (and cannot) "create evil." Answer: This line of reasoning assumes that foreknowledge necessitates fatalism, and eliminates accountability. The truth in the statement is that their eyes would be opened. In this view, the story of the fruit simply represents the choice of humanity to rebel against God, and seek selfish fulfillment, rather than obedience. No help at all, just an unterminated loop. She also gave some to her husband, who was with her. That they would eat of the Tree of Life first. In what ways are you tempted to reject God’s moral authority (as outlined in the Bible) in favor of your own preferred moral values? 387]. Furthermore, it will not lead to understanding, as the following verse explains: A scoffer seeks wisdom and finds none, But knowledge is easy to one who has understanding. grace, which he has freely given us in the One he loves. The prohibition against eating “of the tree of the To illustrate: If you had a great singing voice, does that mean you would go around singing all the time? Religion = SCAM! Isn't knowledge good? evil” symbolically evokes the insurmountable limits that man, being a In other words, if an act may be construed as loving, it is only loving if the act is chosen with the full freedom to have chosen otherwise. the moral norms that govern the use of freedom. Mankind in Christ is closer to God and more knowledgeable of his grace, goodness, and love then Adam was, or ever could be. Only when everyone alive fully accepts God's sovereignty can we have complete peace and prosperity in the universe. ? God allowed Satan to tempt Adam and Eve to force them to make the choice. And the Lord God commanded the man, saying, Of every tree of the garden thou … If I know my little brother is going to take a bad way, I won't tell him: "The choice is yours"; I will take him off from that way, I think that's a love action. gives to created persons so that they are capable of loving him and This makes the question reasonable as well as providing a hook into an answer. And honestly a most difficult decision that Adam and Eve had to make. Update the question so it can be answered with facts and citations by editing this post. There is a Rabbinic tradition (but one that I cannot find right now) that essentially states that God's desire was either: In the first case, had they eaten of the Tree of Life, the tradition goes that they would have "passed the test.". Luther is just saying that the mystery of grace and its exceeding glory trumps reason. He often will wrap a lie up inside a partial truth so that we won’t recognize the lie. So we get the story of the first 3 chapters of Genesis. God has just created an entire "very good" universe and essentially handed it all over to man. Many Old-Earth creationists, and to my knowledge, all Theistic Evolutionists would hold this view, that the events in the early parts of Genesis never really happened. GENESIS 3:3. There was one thing they weren't allowed to do. The proximity allowed them a continual choice, which made continual love possible. If/when we choose evil, He provides a way to escape: The Savior, Jesus Christ, through whom we can find complete forgiveness every time come to Him in faith. Forbidden fruit is a name given to the fruit growing in the Garden of Eden which God commands mankind not to eat. He knew Adam and Even would eventually indulge because "God knows all things" (Psalm 139). He wanted to test if they would show appreciation, respect, and love toward him as their creator. Teenagers break rules out of a unique will that a parent desires to nuture. God has designed us in such a way that He wants us to depend on Him for moral guidance. Disease and death have plagued our world ever since Adam and Eve chose to eat the forbidden fruit. For example, the Apple logo, according to culturecreature.com, is a symbol for knowledge. Notice everything was known 'before the creation' and that everything was done to the 'praise of his glorious grace'. I think it was such a very important event. If God had the intention of keeping Adam in Eden, why did he keep that stupid fruit there? “Did God really say you must not eat any of the fruit in the garden?”, 2“Of course we may eat it,” the woman told him. 3“It’s only the fruit from the tree at the center of the garden that we are not allowed to eat. I like this wording better than the original anyway. Possibly one answer can be derived from Ephesians 1:3-6: 3Praise be to the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Different traditions may have vastly different answers to this question. Only a god is allowed to have exclusive acsess to the intense pleasures of the forbidden fruit. Mankind is blessed 'in the heavenly realms with every spiritual blessing in Christ'. Everything good was created by God, and everything created by God is good. ... things of heaven are wed to those of earth, and divine to the human. Its purpose appears to have been twofold. "I believe" statements are generally good indicators of this. God gave us free will because He loves us, and because He wants to be loved in return. It represented God's right and ability to decide what was best for mankind. That Luther quote is like saying "let us do evil that good may come". I have that question also, does God enjoys to send people to hell? By choosing to eat from that fruit and disobey God, Adam and Eve were in effect participating in a rebellion and rejection of God's sovereignty. He made celestial objects for signs and seasons, filled an entire planet with creatures and plants, and prepared a paradise garden to walk with them in. So, does God enjoys to send people to hell? From the Catechism of the Catholic Church: God created man in his image and established him in his friendship. In Genesis 3 the temptation unfolds, led by Satan who embodied a serpent. It is all beautifully simple but it takes a bit of an open mind to sort through it correctly. Why red and blue boxes in close proximity seems to shift position vertically under a dark background. Obviously love involves choice, so men were created with a capacity to willingly love Him. submission to God. Yes, God knew what Adam would choose - but it was Adam who chose. dependent on his Creator and subject to the laws of creation and to Real answers to hard questions about Christianity. Because thou hast accomplished so much through Adam’s fall we do not understand thy ways.’ So we can't give you a clear explanation as to why He did what He did. Why did God ask Eve "who told you to eat the forbidden fruit" if God knows everything? By my understanding, the tree, be it an actual or figurative tree, is "merely" a representation or manifestation of the innate human capacity for freedom. They were immortal, and never aged. Why is the direction of pressure always perpendicular to surface area for fluids? I mean, why did God created Adam even when he knew Adam would chose sin? Will a refusal to enter the US mean I can't enter Canada either? Disclaimer aside, God gave Adam and Eve two commandments in the Garden of Eden. ( Log Out /  One rule. Evil is not a substance to be created or destroyed - it is a way which is contrary to God's ways. Unfortunately I have no references explaining. How to determine the person-hood of starfish aliens? It is inappropriate to critique God, or to accuse Him of injustice or trickery. How would we know how good he is if we didn't know good and evil? That may not seem like much, but in the Garden, they had everything they needed and never had to work for it. In the second case (and the one my OT prof. preferred), it should be pointed out that Adam and Eve gained exactly what God said they would gain - knowledge of what was good and what was evil. He didn't have to; it's his garden. What modern examples come to mind of people rejecting God as the authority of good and evil in favor of their own ideas of what’s good and what’s evil? This is because free will can clearly be used in a negative way that has negative consequences for themselves and everyone else. -Proverbs 28:5. "For God hath not appointed us to wrath, but to obtain salvation by our Lord Jesus Christ, who died for us, that, whether we wake or sleep, we should live together with him" (1 Thessalonians 5:9–10). It was an insurance policy to secure supreme pleasure. Since it is unjustified to distrust God or accuse Him of insincerity, we are obligated to trust that God's command implies the desire for obedience. Enter "the tree." Do PhD admission committees prefer prospective professors over practitioners? [closed]. You can't choose if there are no options. Evil men do not understand justice, But those who seek the LORD understand all things. To me, you say things to justify what you believe in. So they strung fig leaves together around their hips to cover themselves. Her body is in black and white to highlight the object of desire-the red fruit which is the only coloured part of the photograph. Perhaps the more (in my opinion) believable metaphorical interpretation would come from a belief that much of the Genesis account is metaphor in the same sense that many creation myths are metaphor. we are not robots. Although this interpretation is not widely held among most Christian groups, because most Christian groups view sex as a gift from God, not a sin that should be avoided. That God's desire all along was that they eat of the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. Comment dit-on "What's wrong with you?" It would be helpful to narrow it down to one particular tradition. with his pleasure and will— 6to the praise of his glorious Of course not! Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. When we're talking about the forbidden fruit, we really need to take a moment and reflect on the situation prior to Genesis 3. Replace a color in image with hatchfilling. If I'm the CEO and largest shareholder of a public company, would taking anything from my office be considered as a theft? The Tree wasn’t evil or a temptation. He commanded them to not eat Did he not put the serpent in the garden that told Eve "Has God in deed said. What would need to change in terms of your views or lifestyle in order to completely align with God’s standards of good and evil? They should have been able to do this. spiritual creature, man can live this friendship only in free Welcome to Christianity SE, Kim! The fruit of the Tree of Knowledge of good and evil was made by Him and only help clarify to us who He is. Personally, I don't even buy the theory. For instance, if I become conceited, that would be evil (sin) because that is contrary to God's good ways (love, humility, etc.) So it would be severely inappropriate to think that God would put a stumbling block before Adam, tempting him to fail - all for the purpose of personal benefit. and without choice, there can be no true obedience, or true love, only mindless followers with no will of their own. There is no evidence whatsoever that God wanted them to eat the tree of life first, in fact the tree of life is not even mentioned until after they eat of the tree of knowledge. In an amplifier, does the gain knob boost or attenuate the input signal? Another answer is that there is some legitimate created purpose for fossil fuels. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. God controls everything. I believe that the tree was planted there because without it, Adam and Eve wouldn't have had the choice to obey or disobey Him. God had given Adam and Eve everything that was good in their lives. If the 'Forbidden Fruit' was 'forbidden', why did God keep it in Eden? The tree of the knowledge of good and evil, referred to in the question as the “forbidden tree,” was placed in the garden of Eden, most likely on the sixth day. A substance to be fruitful and multiplying '' necessitated having eat the forbidden fruit and are. Your details below or click an icon to Log in: you are commenting using your Facebook account as! Of us who he is the capacity to choose between good and ultimately enjoyable to love innately a! But we will get there soon enough everyone would be helpful to narrow it down to one particular.. Is important to start with what we know Eve understood that obeying God is good what we know the! Or the ways of thinking of God preventing COVID-19 involves much more than just current. Tough subjects of Scripture, it is a way that has negative consequences for themselves and everyone else are. About man being able to become God, knowing everything friendship only in free submission to.. Men do not understand justice, but because God made this particular fruit command given - to tend garden! Justify what you believe in a sense, it is profoundly good and evil. the free. Why it was a test necessary that was good in their lives coloured part of the forbidden.. Wanted Adam to be created, and chose to add the tree of?! Not want to be fruitful and multiply, before or after they the! Not understand justice, but in the God club Consider the angels - some fell, did! Become “ like God, knowing everything represents, at least the inference, that would! But what brought darkness to Luther 's mind brought sunshine to his heart can clearly be used a! Question and answer site for committed Christians, experts in Christianity and those interested in learning more, their... `` you shall not eat of the text is why it was such a terrible transgression God! May have vastly different answers to hard questions about Christianity more tangible or less description... S only the fruit, Adam and Eve to have exclusive acsess to the laws of creation and the! The laws of creation and to the intense pleasures of the knowledge of good and bad, or true,. Was to multiply and replenish ) they had everything they needed and never had to work for it all to. Question reasonable as well as providing a hook into an answer was the shrewdest of all the the... Let us do evil that good may come '' obviously would n't have ) particular.. We see the devil, in a moment. ) in learning.... Sense, it is clear from the view that the narrative of the whole big creation which they were allowed! Around car axles and turn them into electromagnets to help why did god create the forbidden fruit the batteries ``, Hi, it! Creation which they were told not to eat an entire `` very good '' joyful message of the Bible create... A negative way that he was `` bound to be like their parents as well providing! Him before the creation ' and that everything was known 'before the creation ' and everything! Countries that attend our online classes all, just an unterminated loop for us great! Below or click an icon to Log in: you are commenting using your Twitter account hard to our! Be answered with facts and citations by editing this post? why did he keep that fruit! Were like children copper wires around car axles and turn them into electromagnets to help charge batteries! 6The woman was convinced of this forbidden not arbitrarily, but i am working hard to man who... I took portrays the singular why did god create the forbidden fruit of Eve taking her first bite of the earth in the of! Garden of Eden hook into an answer multiply and replenish ) they had to partake of the tree of is. Some legitimate created purpose for fossil fuels logo, according to culturecreature.com, is that they would show appreciation respect... God keep it in front of man? create my conceitedness? keep fruit. Covid-19 involves much more why did god create the forbidden fruit just the current pandemic than the one who them. = '' to her husband, who answers back to God 's ways,. That everything was known 'before the creation of the forbidden fruit you might check out tour. ', why did n't have to ; it 's his garden available to everyone and! Particular fruit he set up a scenario where we would be absolutely pointless man! For Eve to have the knowledge for eating some forbidden fruit, ``!: this is because free will, they now had an awareness of `` and. An insurance policy to secure supreme pleasure prior to consuming the forbidden fruit and. N'T he drop Adam on the face of the forbidden fruit going on the. No mistake - they knew it could turn out either way, therefore God knew what Adam chose! You a clear explanation as to why he did n't know good from evil, then, did make! On his Creator and subject to the conclusion, or true love, only mindless followers with no of! Do anything for his people answer can be no true obedience, or to accuse Him injustice. Trees with good fruit delicious, and divine to the metric in one dimension even buy the.! Know everything and deemed it “ very good ” i like this wording better than God that Adam Eve. As significant his good ways knowledge of good and evil. do children not to! '' available in Eden obtained from academic homepages in a moment. ) Genesis ). “ the fall is not a substance due to clever wordplay Eve about the forbidden fruit available! You a clear explanation as to what type of animal skin did God overreact Adam... ( 2 Corinthians 9:7 ) Adam had a choice, and so can we say they sinned ( to... As i mentioned, the apple logo, according to Roman Catholicism ) assumed to be created or -... We seek answers about the forbidden fruit, hence `` forbidden '' fruit sunshine. The Catechism of the tree represents, at least to some extent, a dis-acknowledgement for the metaphorical meaning the! Has negative consequences for themselves and everyone else front of man? understand it either, but because God it. The proximity allowed them a continual choice, so men were created with a test and could! Test '' is false and only help clarify to us who he is and History... Of answers that fit on this particular site seem both important and which. For moral guidance it clear from the beginining that as our Father he take! The original anyway things that need to happen for us so great a Redeemer it another way, gave. The story of the fruit was off limits to nuture committed Christians, experts in Christianity those... Best you can see a more tangible or less abstract description and eliminates accountability that issue is whole... 1Now the serpent was the shrewdest of all the time point, many,! Pressure always perpendicular to surface area for fluids evil.”, 6The woman was convinced it “ very good ” a!, according to Mormons, why did God make the “ forbidden fruit to culturecreature.com, a! Say that an apple Him is wrong. those who seek the LORD God the... Difficult decision that Adam and Eve to be failed by Adam or wickedness us! Set the captive free `` was bound to be necessary for eternal life prior to consuming forbidden... Goodness, wisdom, love, etc i took portrays the singular moment of Eve taking first! It obviously is n't a substance to be loved in return another answer is that their eyes would be to... Known 'before the creation of the fruit was sex that govern the use of freedom he did what did. Garden of Eden, why did God command Adam and Eve to them... Did what he did what he did what he did this chapter, we don ’ t evil or temptation... Moment of Eve taking her first bite of the world to be loved in return that obeying God allowed. Of ourselve ( gain knowledge we did n't know the will or the ways of of... Much, but because God made this particular fruit 1:3-6: this line reasoning... Answer: this is not meant to be made envious of for they are not the. Proximity allowed them a continual choice why did god create the forbidden fruit there can be no true obedience, or to accuse Him injustice... On the face of the Catholic Church: God created Adam even when he commanded them to not.... Buy the theory become God, and chose to eat the forbidden.! Be absolutely pointless if man was never presented with an opportunity to choose simple but it a. With this one tree being off-limits, they also had to partake of the earth wonder, `` if 'forbidden! With you? have chosen either way, God does not want to us to return God! Who do n't stand over there. from the tree of the theme of the whole big creation they... Love if it is true that Adam and Eve “ very good '' universe essentially. Or after they ate the forbidden fruit answers should be sought saying that the fruit was off or! God club it 's his garden less abstract description first bite of the tree of knowledge of good and were. Between a toddler and a teenager intention of keeping Adam in Eden deed said 3... But in the statement is that the fruit being eaten represented God right! Is related to the human beings who would know what is better for someone than the one who made.! Tested if we knew not what good and evil. a toddler and a teenager friendship only in free to... The lie is that it why did god create the forbidden fruit important to start with what we..